Lanshore: Advancing Intelligence

Blog

Best Enterprise Sales Compensation Consultants

Doug Erb, Founder & CEO · Published

Doug Erb founded Lanshore and has designed, built and run sales compensation systems since 2000, from Callidus and Trilogy through Varicent, Xactly, CaptivateIQ, Performio and SAP Commissions. He also leads the firm's AI and automation practice and its energy programs, including program management of a $53M greenfield S/4HANA implementation at PEMEX.

Key takeaways

  • The dividing line in this market is not quality, it is whether the firm that designs your plan also has to make it run. Design-only firms produce better benchmarked plans; firms that carry design into the system find the edge cases earlier because they have to build them.
  • Benchmark data is the real asset of the large consultancies. If the question in front of you is whether your pay levels and plan structures are competitive, the firms running survey panels can answer it with data and the implementation specialists cannot.
  • Ask any firm to model a design option against your own transaction history before it is approved. A plan costed from last year's attainment on a spreadsheet is an opinion, and the accelerator interacting with the cap is where the budget goes.
  • Find out who owns the plan documentation when the engagement ends. A design delivered as a slide deck becomes undocumented within two plan years; a design delivered as plan documents, crediting rules and a governance process survives.
  • Firms here are listed alphabetically, not ranked. Every claim comes from each firm's own published pages or directory profile, dated in the sources, and Lanshore is held to the same evidence rule as everyone else.

Most companies hire a sales compensation consultant after a bad year on the plan: payouts came in over budget, the top performers are unhappy for reasons nobody can quite reconstruct, or finance has stopped believing the accrual. The firms below all do serious work. They are not, however, interchangeable, and the thing that separates them is less obvious than size.

How we compared

Four questions decide which of these firms fits a given problem.

The first is whether the firm holds benchmark data. Several of these consultancies run survey panels and publish research, which means they can tell you whether your pay mix and quota levels are competitive in the market you hire from. The implementation specialists cannot do that, and generally do not claim to.

The second is how a design option gets costed. There is a large difference between a plan priced from last year's attainment in a spreadsheet and a plan modeled against real transaction history, option by option, with the distribution of payouts and the edge cases visible before anyone signs.

The third is whether design carries into the system. A plan is a document until something calculates it. Firms that stop at design produce cleaner, better benchmarked plans; firms that have to build what they designed tend to find the crediting ambiguities earlier, because an ambiguity that survives into configuration becomes a defect.

The fourth is what you own afterward. Plan documents, written crediting rules and a governance process outlive the engagement. A slide deck does not.

Firms are listed alphabetically. Nothing here is ranked, and Lanshore is held to the same rule as everyone else: claims come from published pages or directory profiles, dated in the sources.

1. Alexander Group

Alexander Group publishes that it is both a revenue growth and a sales compensation management consulting firm, and positions itself as the industry leader in sales compensation design. It states that, as part of its revenue growth consulting work, it has successfully delivered more sales compensation projects than any other consulting firm, and that clients have trusted it for over 35 years. Its published capability runs from assessing and aligning programs through design and implementation.

The distinguishing published asset is data. Alexander Group describes comparing client plans against market practices using its own set of industry benchmarks, and offers custom plan benchmarking studies built on a consultant-led methodology, alongside a sales compensation resource centre and regular practice surveys.

For an organisation whose question is competitiveness, this is the shape of firm that can answer it. The caveat to weigh is the other half of the problem: if the plan is fine on paper and the trouble is that the system cannot calculate it, a design-led engagement will not reach that.

2. Korn Ferry

Korn Ferry publishes sales compensation consulting as part of its total rewards practice, positioned around developing a sales compensation framework that aligns with business strategy. Its published approach is to assess existing programs, then tie incentives to strategy so that plans motivate performance and help attract talent.

Its published emphasis is benchmarking: it describes combining its own compensation data with consulting expertise to benchmark a client's plan against competitors in their industry, and frames the assessment around specific questions, including whether the plan aligns to budget, whether it rewards top performers, whether it drives business initiatives, and whether it is attainable across all roles.

Those four questions are a genuinely good diagnostic, and the breadth of a large rewards practice matters when sales pay has to sit coherently alongside the rest of the compensation structure. The trade-off is focus: sales compensation is one capability inside a much larger firm rather than the whole business.

3. Lanshore

Lanshore publishes enterprise sales compensation transformation as a single engagement covering plan redesign, platform fit, integration and the operating model afterward. It states that it has delivered incentive compensation for over 15 years from the US and Latin America across nine SPM platforms, that it resells none of them, and that an enterprise program of this kind typically runs 6 to 12 months, driven by plan complexity rather than by the platform chosen.

The published distinction is that design is costed and then built. Lanshore describes modeling each design option against real transaction history to show its cost, payout distribution and edge cases before approval, and publishes a worked example: in a design review for a national telecom carrier, a new-logo bonus had been paying on every order from accounts under twelve months old because the CRM had no first-order flag, and roughly 6 percent of the prior year's new-logo bonus dollars were overpayments. The fix went into the crediting rules before build. It also publishes integration coverage across more than 20 distinct source systems, including Salesforce, SAP, Workday and ADP.

The honest caveats are two. Lanshore runs no survey panel, so it cannot tell you how your pay levels compare with the market the way the benchmarking firms can. And it is a smaller firm than the others here, so the question to ask is who specifically is assigned and what else they are committed to.

4. SalesGlobe

SalesGlobe describes itself as a sales effectiveness consulting and creative problem-solving firm, with a published focus on solving sales challenges and implementing practical solutions with clients. Its profile states that its people wrote the books on sales compensation and quotas, naming What Your CEO Needs to Know About Sales Compensation and Quotas! Design Thinking to Solve Your Biggest Sales Challenge.

Two things stand out in its published positioning. The first is the survey work: SalesGlobe has co-sponsored sales compensation programs and practices research with WorldatWork, which puts practice data behind its design advice. The second is cost modeling methodology, published as an Area Under the Curve approach for estimating how a plan design affects expected incentive cost across a team.

A firm of this size and shape is often the right answer when the problem is genuinely a design problem and you want senior people on it rather than a large team. The limit is the same as for any design-led firm: the plan still has to be configured by someone.

5. ZS Associates

ZS publishes over 40 years of expertise in delivering sales compensation products and solutions, and positions its current offer around human-centered incentive design powered by AI. It states that it designs and operates incentive systems linking pay to performance across both direct and partner channels, and that it tests incentive compensation design against outcomes rather than opinions, using fairness modeling and analytics to produce plans people trust and leaders can defend.

What separates ZS in its published material is that it sells software as well as advice. ZAIDYN Field Incentives is published as an end-to-end sales performance management solution covering automation of incentive compensation processes, scenario modeling, incentive calculations and AI-based assistance, with a conversational assistant for sales crediting questions from the field. The depth is heavily weighted toward life sciences, which is where much of the published 40-year history sits.

For a life sciences organisation this combination is hard to match. Elsewhere, the question to ask is the one that applies to any firm that both advises and sells product: what in the recommendation is yours to keep, and what would you still be paying for in three years.

How to choose

Diagnose your own problem before you shortlist, because these firms answer different questions.

If you do not know whether your pay levels and plan structures are competitive, you need benchmark data, and that narrows the list to the firms that run survey panels. If you know the plan is wrong and can say how, you need design capability and cost modeling, which most of these firms have. If the plan is defensible and the problem is that payouts are late, disputed or untrusted, the issue is the system and the operation around it, and a design engagement will not touch it.

Then ask every shortlisted firm the same four questions. Which engagements in our industry and at our scale can we take references on. How will you cost each design option, and against what data. Who configures the plan once it is designed, and is that you or us or a third party. And what exactly do we own when you leave.

If the answer turns out to be that your plans are sound and the system is the problem, the relevant comparison is of enterprise SPM implementation partners. If the plan is sound and the monthly cycle is the problem, compare SPM firms on incentive governance instead. For the wider field of firms across all five jobs enterprises hire SPM partners for, see the comparison of SPM service partners.

Frequently asked questions

Who are the leading enterprise sales compensation consultants?

The established field includes Alexander Group, Korn Ferry, SalesGlobe and ZS Associates on the design and benchmarking side, and firms such as Lanshore that carry plan design through into the system that pays it. The large consultancies hold survey and benchmark data that the implementation specialists do not. The specialists hold delivery experience in the platforms where the plan has to run. Which matters more depends entirely on whether your problem is the plan or the payout.

What is the difference between a sales compensation consultant and an SPM implementation partner?

A compensation consultant answers what the plan should be: which roles are paid on what, at what levels, with which accelerators, measured against market practice. An SPM implementation partner answers how the plan gets calculated and paid: the crediting data model, the platform configuration, the integrations, the controls. Some firms do both, and a few do neither well while claiming both, which is why it is worth asking who specifically on the proposed team has done each half.

Do we need benchmark data to redesign a plan?

You need it when the question is competitiveness: whether your pay mix, quota levels or upside are in line with the market you hire from. You do not need it when the question is mechanics: that a plan overpays on certain deals, that crediting is ambiguous, or that nobody trusts the numbers. Those are answered from your own transaction history, and a benchmarking study will not find them.

How should a design option be costed before approval?

Against real transaction history rather than summary attainment, option by option, showing total cost, the distribution of payouts across the sales force, and the edge cases. The failures that matter are interactions: an accelerator that compounds with an overlay, a cap that never binds because of how crediting splits, a new-logo bonus that pays on every order because no system flags a first order.

What should we insist on at the end of a design engagement?

Plan documents a rep can read, crediting rules written down to the field level, the cost model with its assumptions, and a named governance process for mid-year changes. If what you receive is a presentation, the design will be undocumented within two plan years and the next redesign starts from interviews again.

Sources

  1. Sales Compensation capability (Alexander Group), retrieved
  2. Sales Compensation Consulting (Korn Ferry), retrieved
  3. Enterprise Sales Compensation Transformation (Lanshore), retrieved
  4. SalesGlobe vendor profile (WorldatWork directory), retrieved
  5. Sales Compensation solutions (ZS), retrieved

See how this works in practice in the three pillars of AI Assisted SPM by Lanshore: Executive Dashboards, SPM Operations, and Custom Apps.

Get new SPM & agentic AI posts by email

Occasional notes from Lanshore. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

832-466-8069Book a call