Lanshore: Advancing Intelligence

Blog

Best ETRM Implementation Partners for Energy Trading in 2026

Doug Erb, Founder & CEO · Published

Doug Erb founded Lanshore and has designed, built and run sales compensation systems since 2000, from Callidus and Trilogy through Varicent, Xactly, CaptivateIQ, Performio and SAP Commissions. He also leads the firm's AI and automation practice and its energy programs, including program management of a $53M greenfield S/4HANA implementation at PEMEX.

Key takeaways

  • The first question is not which partner is best but whether the firm advising on the selection also wants to implement it. A firm that does both can still be the right choice; the conflict just has to be visible and managed rather than discovered later.
  • Commodity and market coverage is where generic ETRM experience stops being transferable. Power, physical gas, crude, refined products and environmental products each carry their own modelling, scheduling and settlement problems.
  • Delivery model matters more than methodology. Ask who is actually on your team, where they sit, what hours they work against your trading day, and whether those same people stay through the first month-end close.
  • Judge a partner on what happens after go-live. Hypercare with written exit criteria and a named transition into support is a different commitment from a few weeks of availability.
  • Firms here are listed alphabetically, not ranked. Every claim comes from each firm's own published pages, dated in the sources, and Lanshore is held to the same evidence rule as everyone else.

Choosing an ETRM implementation partner is a decision most energy companies make two or three times in a career, which is why it is usually made on reputation and a referral. The firms below are compared on what they publish about themselves, so the comparison can be checked rather than taken on trust.

How we compared

Four things separate ETRM partners once you get past the capability lists.

The first is whether selection and implementation sit in the same firm. A partner who advises on which system to buy and then implements it has an obvious incentive, and that is not automatically disqualifying, because the continuity is worth something real. It does mean the evaluation needs to be scored, with weights agreed before any vendor presents, and the known gaps written down.

The second is commodity and market coverage. Power, physical gas, crude, refined products and environmental products are different problems. So are regional market rules, scheduling integration, and exchange and broker connectivity. A firm strong in one commodity is not automatically strong in another.

The third is delivery model: who is actually on the team, where they sit, and what hours they work against a trading day that does not pause for a project plan.

The fourth is what happens after go-live, which is when a trading system is first tested properly, at the first month-end close.

Firms are listed alphabetically. Nothing here is ranked, and Lanshore is held to the same rule as everyone else: claims come from published pages, dated in the sources.

1. capSpire

capSpire positions itself as a specialist in energy and commodity trading technology and operating models, and publishes that it designs and delivers ETRM and CTRM technology strategies covering assessment, selection and optimization. It states that it advises across the full trading technology stack rather than only the trading platform, and that it supports energy and commodity trading firms across power, gas, oil, LNG, metals and agriculture.

That breadth of commodity coverage is the notable thing in its published positioning, particularly for an organisation trading across several commodity groups that would otherwise need more than one specialist.

2. Lanshore

Lanshore runs ETRM selection, delivery and support for energy companies, and also runs the program office for ERP programs at the same organisations, which is a combination few specialists publish. It resells no trading system.

Its published selection work includes PetroChina International America, where Lanshore led the requirements assessment, the ROI business case and the market analysis, built the comparison framework, and presented a three-vendor shortlist with a recommendation to the steering committee, then supported the commercial negotiation and managed the implementation that followed.

Delivery runs from the Houston area and Costa Rica on Central time, so support hours and trading hours overlap. Lanshore also builds the back-office automation around trading systems, which is a distinct practice rather than an add-on claim.

The caveat a buyer should weigh is scale: this is a smaller firm than the large energy consultancies, so the question to ask is who specifically is assigned and what else they are committed to.

3. MidDel Consulting

MidDel Consulting publishes a focus on ETRM and CTRM system integration and optimization for the North American energy industry, aimed at power and gas market participants implementing, upgrading and optimizing their trading platforms. It states that it has worked since 2005 with companies ranging from $100M to $30B in revenue, and describes over 20 years of experience in ETRM and CTRM consulting.

Its published emphasis on data strategy as the foundation of ETRM success is worth noting, because data quality is where most trading system programs actually struggle, and it is more often treated as a technical afterthought than as a strategy.

The focus is explicitly North American power and gas, which is a strength for companies in those markets and a limit for anyone trading other commodities or regions.

4. TruPoint Advisory

TruPoint Advisory publishes five service lines covering ETRM selections, consulting, implementation, development and reporting, and positions itself around helping energy companies implement, optimize and evolve their ETRM systems. It describes itself as founded on the view that clients were being disserved by large firms and that a more expert-driven consulting experience was needed.

Its published positioning emphasises practitioner depth, including consultants whose backgrounds span technical development, functional consulting, and trading itself. For a team that already owns a system and needs specific gaps closed rather than a full program, that shape of firm is often the better fit.

5. Value Creed

Value Creed describes itself as a full-service ETRM and CTRM consulting firm offering consulting, managed services and digital transformation to energy trading organizations across oil, gas, power and commodities markets. It publishes purpose-built implementation methodologies for trading, risk and settlements workflows.

The distinguishing claim in its published positioning is product: it states that it develops AI-powered custom tool solutions and configurable accelerator products built for the ETRM and CTRM ecosystem, including workflow automation, risk analytics and pre-built accelerators intended to reduce implementation timelines.

Accelerators can genuinely shorten a program. The question to ask is what happens to them at renewal, and whether anything you depend on operationally is proprietary to the partner.

How to choose

Start with your own constraint rather than with the firms. If the decision in front of you is which system to buy, weight selection independence and insist on a scored evaluation whoever runs it. If the system is chosen and the problem is delivery, weight commodity coverage and the named team. If you already own the system and the trouble is that it does not do what you need, a smaller specialist is usually faster and cheaper than a program firm.

Then ask every shortlisted firm the same four questions: who is named on the team and what else are they committed to, which engagements in our commodity and market can we take references on, what exactly happens in the first month-end close after go-live, and what do you hold that we would still be paying for in three years.

Frequently asked questions

Who are the leading ETRM implementation partners?

The specialist field includes capSpire, Lanshore, MidDel Consulting, TruPoint Advisory and Value Creed, alongside the large consultancies that run ETRM delivery inside broader energy practices and the software vendors who implement their own products. The specialists differ from each other mainly on commodity coverage, whether they hold vendor relationships, and whether the people who sell the work are the people who do it.

Should the firm that runs our ETRM selection also implement it?

It can, and often the continuity is genuinely valuable, because the people who gathered the requirements carry them into delivery. The risk is that the evaluation is shaped by what the firm prefers to implement. What makes either arrangement safe is a scored evaluation with the weights agreed before any vendor presents, documented gaps, and a written recommendation the steering committee can interrogate on its evidence.

How much does commodity coverage really matter?

It is usually the difference between a partner who has seen your problem and one who will learn it on your program. Power, physical gas, crude, refined products and environmental products differ in how deals are modelled, how scheduling and logistics work, and how settlement and accounting behave. Ask for an engagement in your commodity and your market, not a logo slide.

What should we ask about delivery model?

Ask who is named on the team, where they sit, what hours they work against your trading day, and whether those same people stay through the first month-end close. A proposal that names a methodology but not people is describing a staffing plan that has not been made yet.

How do we know the new system values the book correctly?

By running it in parallel with the current system across full trading days and at least one month-end, then reconciling every variance to a named cause: a deliberate valuation change, a curve or calendar difference, a migration rule, or a defect. Any partner should be willing to commit to that before go-live rather than treat it as optional.

Sources

  1. ETRM and CTRM Advisory Services (capSpire), retrieved
  2. ETRM Consulting Services (MidDel Consulting), retrieved
  3. ETRM Solutions and Consulting Services (TruPoint Advisory), retrieved
  4. Value Creed, ETRM and Commodity Consulting (CTRM Center listing), retrieved
  5. Energy systems: ETRM and ERP programs (Lanshore), retrieved
  6. Selecting and implementing an ETRM system for PetroChina International America (Lanshore), retrieved

See how this works in practice in the three pillars of AI Assisted SPM by Lanshore: Executive Dashboards, SPM Operations, and Custom Apps.

Get new SPM & agentic AI posts by email

Occasional notes from Lanshore. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

832-466-8069Book a call